How it shows up
| Stripe reason | subscription_canceled (Subscription canceled) |
|---|---|
| Stripe network code | payment_method_details.card.network_reason_code = C28 |
| PayPal reason for the same claim | CANCELED_RECURRING_BILLING |
| The buyer says | The buyer says they were charged for a subscription after canceling it. |
How to answer it
- Show the buyer did not cancel before the billing date, or canceled after this charge.
- Show the cancellation terms the buyer accepted, and any renewal notice you sent.
- Show the buyer kept using the service after the date they say they canceled.
If the buyer has a point, a refund before the deadline can cost less than the dispute fee and a loss. Once a dispute is open, the bank still decides, so mention any refund in your response.
Evidence checklist
- Cancellation policyThe policy as the buyer saw it.Stripe field:
cancellation_policy - How the policy was shownWhere and when the buyer saw it before subscribing.Stripe field:
cancellation_policy_disclosure - Why the subscription was not canceledOr, if it was, why this payment is still valid.Stripe field:
cancellation_rebuttal - Renewal notice or the buyer's acknowledgementThe reminder you sent, or a message where the buyer accepts the renewal.Stripe field:
customer_communication - Access or download logLogins, downloads or usage after the payment, with IP addresses and timestamps.Stripe field:
access_activity_log - Proof the service was providedThe service date and a signed contract, work order, booking record or check-in.Stripe field:
service_date,service_documentation - Your summary letterA short statement that names the claim, answers it, and points to each attachment.Stripe field:
uncategorized_text,uncategorized_file
Filter this by product type in the Stripe evidence checklist, then draft the cover letter with the rebuttal letter generator.
Prevent it next time
- Send a reminder before each renewal and before a trial converts.
- Make canceling easy and confirm it by email.
Read next: How Amex inquiries and chargebacks work · How a chargeback works, step by step.
Questions
What does American Express reason code C28 mean?
C28 is "Canceled Recurring Billing". The card member says they were charged for a subscription after canceling it.
How does American Express C28 show up in Stripe?
Stripe shows the dispute with reason "subscription_canceled" (Subscription canceled) and the network code "C28" in payment_method_details.card.network_reason_code. On PayPal the same kind of claim has the reason CANCELED_RECURRING_BILLING.
What evidence answers a American Express C28 chargeback?
Cancellation policy; How the policy was shown; Why the subscription was not canceled; Renewal notice or the buyer's acknowledgement; Access or download log; Proof the service was provided; Your summary letter. Pick what applies to the order and put the strongest proof first.
Answer it from the support case
In Rebutdesk a Stripe or PayPal dispute opens inside the buyer's support case, with the reason and deadline on it. You tick the messages and notes that prove your side, and they go into one evidence PDF with your statement. See how it works.
14 days free, no card needed. Already have an account? Sign in
Related codes
- Visa 13.2 Canceled Recurring
- Mastercard 4841 Canceled Recurring or Digital Goods Transactions
- Discover 4541 Recurring Payment
Code names and the Stripe category follow Stripe's reason code categoriesand reason code pages, checked October 29, 2026. Networks revise their rules; your processor's dispute notice is the authority for a given dispute.