A chargeback is a payment reversal that the cardholder's bank starts, not you. It exists to protect cardholders from billing errors and fraud, so the system is built to move the money first and look at the evidence afterwards. Knowing the order of events tells you where you still have leverage, and where you have none.
The people involved
- Cardholder: your customer, or someone using their card.
- Issuer: the bank that issued the card. It files the dispute and makes the decision.
- Card network: Visa, Mastercard, American Express or Discover. It sets the rules, time limits and reason codes. Stripe notes that with American Express the network itself can be the issuer.
- Acquirer and processor: your merchant bank and the company you take payments through, such as Stripe, Shopify Payments, PayPal or Adyen. They pass the dispute to you and your evidence to the issuer, and they set your deadline.
- You: the merchant, with one chance to answer.
Step 1: something goes wrong, or seems to
Every chargeback starts with a cardholder who does not like a charge. The causes fall into a few groups: they do not recognize it, the order did not arrive, it arrived but was not what they expected, they cancelled or returned and are still waiting for a credit, or someone really did use their card without permission. The reason code on the dispute tells you which group the issuer put it in.
Card rules expect the cardholder to try the merchant first for many of these. Visa's rules, for example, make the issuer wait 15 calendar days in several not-received, returned and credit cases before filing, and for not-received disputes processed from October 23, 2027 the issuer will have to record the date the cardholder tried to resolve it with you, how they contacted you and what happened. That is why the support conversation matters so much: it is the first step of the dispute process whether you think of it that way or not. The ecommerce customer service playbook covers that stage.
Step 2: the issuer files an inquiry or a chargeback
The issuer reviews the claim and either asks for information or files a chargeback straight away.
| Inquiry | Chargeback | |
|---|---|---|
| Money moves? | No | Yes, the disputed amount and a fee leave your balance |
| Who uses it | Mostly American Express and Discover, per Stripe | All networks |
| Can you still refund? | Yes. A full refund closes it; a partial one may not | No, only through the dispute itself on Stripe and Shopify |
| If you ignore it | It can escalate to a chargeback you cannot contest | You lose by default |
American Express describes this in its own merchant guide: if it cannot resolve the case with what it has, it sends an inquiry; if the card member gives enough information, it may debit your account up front. The Amex chargeback guide has the details.
Step 3: the processor debits you and starts the clock
On Stripe, the network debits Stripe and Stripe debits your balance for the disputed amount plus a dispute fee, then notifies you by Dashboard, email, webhook and API. Your dispute rate with that network goes up the moment the dispute exists, whether you later win or not. The disputed amount can differ from the charge, for example after currency conversion or when a bank bundles several subscription charges into one dispute.
Fees depend on the processor. Stripe's dispute received fee is non-refundable outside Mexico, and a separate countered fee applies if you respond, returned only if you win. PayPal charges $20 for card chargebacks on payments not made through a PayPal account, and $15 or $30 dispute fees on PayPal checkout payments. Shopify Payments returns the fee if you win. The chargeback fees guide compares them and thefee calculator shows when a dispute is worth fighting.
Step 4: you accept or respond
Your window is set by the processor and is shorter than the network's, because the processor needs time to forward your answer. Stripe says usually 7 to 21 days, Shopify 7 to 21 days, PayPal 10 days for card chargebacks, and American Express 20 days for its inquiries and chargebacks. The exact date is on the dispute. Miss it and you lose. See the chargeback time limits for every network.
Accepting means the cardholder keeps the money and you skip the work. Responding, called representment, means sending evidence that answers the specific reason: proof of delivery for not received, the listing and messages for not as described, the refund record for credit not processed, and the customer's history for fraud. A short rebuttal letter on top tells the reviewer what each attachment proves. On Stripe you submit once; there is no second upload.
Even when the customer says they have withdrawn the dispute, submit evidence. Stripe says submitting evidence is what signals that you do not accept the dispute, and Shopify asks for the bank's withdrawal letter as evidence.
Step 5: the issuer decides
Stripe says the issuer usually has 60 to 75 days to evaluate your evidence and the full lifecycle takes 2 to 3 months. If you win, the debited amount comes back. If you lose, nothing more moves on your side, because the money already left at step 3. On Stripe and Shopify the decision is final for both sides: there is no appeal, though a customer can still withdraw a dispute after a loss on Stripe.
Step 6: sometimes, pre-arbitration
On Visa and Mastercard, an issuer that rejects your evidence can take the case further, and the network makes the final call if neither bank backs down. The deadlines are short and losing at arbitration adds a fee. See pre-arbitration.
Where you can change the outcome
- Before the dispute: a clear billing descriptor, fast answers to "where is my order", and refunds you promised actually sent.
- At the inquiry: answer it, or refund in full if the buyer has a point. Stripe says an inquiry resolved this way carries no dispute fee.
- On fraud warnings: alerts and early fraud warnings let you refund before a dispute is filed.
- In the response: evidence that matches the reason code, assembled before the deadline, not on the last day.
Disputes from PayPal accounts follow PayPal's own process, covered in PayPal disputes for sellers andPayPal chargebacks.
Questions
How does a chargeback work for the merchant?
The cardholder asks their card issuer to reverse a payment. The issuer files a dispute through the card network, your processor debits the disputed amount plus a dispute fee from your balance, and you get a deadline to submit evidence. The issuer then decides, usually within 60 to 75 days on Stripe, and the money either comes back to you or stays with the cardholder.
Who decides a chargeback?
The cardholder's bank (the issuer), under the card network's rules. Stripe says it facilitates the case but has no influence over the outcome, and Shopify says the same for Shopify Payments. For PayPal claims filed with PayPal, PayPal decides; for card chargebacks on PayPal payments, the card issuer decides.
How long does a chargeback take?
Stripe says the full lifecycle usually takes 2 to 3 months: about 7 to 21 days for you to respond and 60 to 75 days for the issuer to decide. Shopify says the card company can take up to 75 days after you submit.
Can I refund a customer after a chargeback is filed?
Not on Stripe or Shopify Payments. Stripe says you cannot issue a refund outside the dispute process while the dispute is open, and Shopify says an order cannot be refunded once a chargeback has started. You can still refund during an inquiry, before it becomes a chargeback.
What is the difference between an inquiry and a chargeback?
An inquiry is a request for information before any money moves. Stripe says American Express and Discover use inquiries most often, and Visa and Mastercard no longer do. A chargeback takes the funds from your balance straight away. Ignoring an inquiry can turn it into a chargeback you cannot win.
Sources: Stripe How disputes work;Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (October 24, 2026 edition, Dispute Condition 13.1); American ExpressHow to Manage and Help Prevent Disputes (2024); Shopify Help CenterResponding to chargebacks and inquiries and Resolving a chargeback; PayPal merchant fees (updated October 1, 2026) and managing chargebacks. Checked October 30, 2026.
Keep the evidence before you need it
Rebutdesk is an open-source helpdesk where Stripe and PayPal disputes open inside the buyer's support case, so the conversation, refunds and shipping events are already in order when the deadline starts. See how it works.
14 days free, no card needed. Already have an account? Sign in
More guides
- Chargeback time limits by card network
- Chargeback representment: what it is and how to win it
- Pre-arbitration chargebacks: what happens after your first response
- How to write a chargeback rebuttal letter
- How to respond to a Stripe dispute
- PayPal disputes for sellers: how to respond and win
- Chargeback vs refund: what's the difference for merchants?
- Chargeback fees: who pays and how much
- Billing descriptors: how to stop 'I don't recognize this charge' disputes
- Chargeback alerts: Ethoca, Verifi CDRN and Rapid Dispute Resolution
- Visa VAMP: the ratio, thresholds and fees for merchants
- Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0: how CE 3.0 works for fraud disputes
- Customer service email templates for online stores
- American Express chargebacks: how inquiries and disputes work
- PayPal chargebacks: what happens when the buyer goes to their bank
- Shopify chargebacks: how to respond and what Shopify does for you
- PayPal Seller Protection: what it covers and how to qualify
- Credit card decline codes: what each one means and when to retry
- Friendly fraud: what it is, how to spot it and how to win
- Ecommerce customer service: a playbook that also prevents chargebacks