Pre-arbitration is the round of a chargeback that comes after you have already answered. Either the issuer has read your evidence and still sides with the cardholder, or your side is challenging the chargeback and the issuer must accept or refuse. If neither side gives way, the case can go to arbitration, where the card network decides and the loser pays a fee. Most small sellers rarely see a pre-arbitration chargeback, but when one arrives the deadlines are short and the stakes are higher than in the first round.

Where pre-arbitration sits in the chargeback cycle

  1. Chargeback (dispute). The issuer disputes the payment for a reason code and the funds are pulled from your balance.
  2. Representment. You answer with evidence through your processor. Visa calls this the Dispute Response, Mastercard the second presentment. See chargeback representment.
  3. Pre-arbitration. The side that disagrees with the last step makes one more attempt, and the other side accepts or declines.
  4. Arbitration. The network reviews the case and assigns liability. Its decision is final apart from any appeal its rules allow.

Some networks start with an inquiry (a request for information) before step 1. That is a pre-dispute stage, not pre-arbitration. Stripe shows inquiries with a warning_ status such as warning_needs_response.

Visa: two flows, Allocation and Collaboration

Visa splits disputes into four categories: 10 fraud, 11 authorization, 12 processing errors and 13 consumer disputes. The Visa rules give the fraud and authorization categories one process and the other two a different one. Processors such as Adyen call them the Allocation flow (categories 10 and 11) and the Collaboration flow (categories 12 and 13).

Allocation flow (fraud and authorization)

There is no Dispute Response step. Your answer to the chargeback is itself a pre-arbitration attempt.

  • The acquirer may make a pre-arbitration attempt within 30 calendar days of the dispute processing date.
  • The issuer has 30 calendar days to respond. It can accept liability or decline. It may decline if, for example, it has new information about the dispute. If you supplied Compelling Evidence (see Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0) and any contact detail matches the issuer's records, the issuer must certify that it contacted the cardholder to review that evidence and explain why they still dispute.
  • The acquirer may then file for arbitration within 10 calendar days of the issuer's pre-arbitration response.

Adyen notes that in this flow the disputed amount is not returned to you when you defend. It opens the pre-arbitration case with your documents automatically, and the issuer's acceptance (a final reversal) is what returns the money.

Collaboration flow (processing errors and consumer disputes)

  • The acquirer has 30 calendar days from the dispute to send a Dispute Response (your representment).
  • The issuer can then make a pre-arbitration attempt within 30 calendar days of the Dispute Response. Visa lists the reasons it can do so: it has new documentation, it changes the dispute condition based on what you sent, or it certifies the cardholder still disputes. If your response met the condition's requirements, the issuer must certify it contacted the cardholder about your evidence and explain why they continue to dispute.
  • The acquirer has 30 calendar days to accept or decline that pre-arbitration attempt.
  • The issuer may file for arbitration within 10 calendar days of the acquirer's response.

The deadlines above are for banks. Your processor gives you less time to answer each step, so act on the date the processor shows. For first-round deadlines, see chargeback time limits.

Mastercard: second presentment, then case filing

Mastercard's developer documentation describes the cycle as a first chargeback by the issuer, a second presentment by the acquirer that moves the funds back, and then pre-arbitration and arbitration case filing by the issuer, for the second presentment amount or less. Mastercom only allows a pre-arbitration case once the chargeback cycle after the second presentment is complete. The receiver can accept or reject the case, and if it does not respond, the system rejects it automatically under the chargeback rules. The filer can then escalate to arbitration, where Mastercard determines responsibility.

Adyen's Mastercard page says the issuer must file pre-arbitration within 45 days of your defense, that arbitration can take several months, and that the funds return to your balance while the issuer reviews your defense. Its general timeframe table gives a pre-arbitration window of 8 to 28 days depending on the reason code, so the exact deadline depends on the code and on which step you are at. Check the case in your processor.

What arbitration costs

Visa's rules say the party found responsible pays both the transaction amount and a review fee, that Visa may reject an invalid case and keep the review fee, and that Visa can split liability when one side offered a reasonable compromise. The public rules do not state the fee. Adyen lists a USD 600filing fee charged to the loser of Visa arbitration, and says that if Mastercard rules for the issuer you can incur a fee of up to USD 600. Your processor's contract may add more.

Visa also bars new material at arbitration: a member must not submit documentation that was not previously given to the other side. Your first response is effectively your arbitration file, which is one more reason to get it right the first time.

How Stripe and PayPal handle it

  • Stripe says it does not support the arbitration phase, so you cannot escalate disputes to arbitrators through Stripe. After you submit evidence, the next notice is the final decision, won or lost. In rare cases a lost dispute later becomes a "late win" when the issuer moves money outside the normal cycle. You may also, rarely, receive a second dispute on the same payment, for example under a different reason code; each one needs its own response.
  • Stripe compliance disputes are a separate path. When an issuer says a payment broke Visa or Mastercard rules (Visa calls the issuer's filing pre-compliance), contesting it means Stripe collects 500 USD for network costs on top of its dispute fees, refunded if you win.
  • PayPal card chargebacks are decided by the card issuer. PayPal asks you to respond within 10 days and handles the case with the issuer; its seller documentation does not describe a separate pre-arbitration step you act on.

When to accept pre-arbitration

Adyen's advice is to decline only when you are confident the chargeback is invalid or can refute the issuer's reasoning, and that your first defense should already have been enough. In practice:

  • Accept when the issuer brought new, valid information, such as a return you did not record or a refund that never went through.
  • Accept when the disputed amount is small next to a possible arbitration fee plus your time.
  • Accept when your evidence did not address the reason code. Arbitration will not let you add what you left out.
  • Decline when the issuer's response just repeats the original claim and your evidence directly disproves it, for example delivery to the verified address for a "not received" claim, or qualifying Compelling Evidence for a fraud claim.

Pre-arbitration usually turns on what the cardholder told their bank after your first response. The buyer's own messages to you, in order, are often the evidence that settles it, so keep the whole support thread with the order.

Fee math matters here too: see chargeback fees and the chargeback fee calculator. Every dispute you receive counts toward your dispute ratio whatever the outcome, which is covered in Visa VAMP.

Questions

What is pre-arbitration in a chargeback?

Pre-arbitration is the stage after your first response, when one side does not accept the other's position and asks it to reconsider before the card network is asked to rule. On Visa consumer disputes, it is the issuer answering your evidence. On Visa fraud disputes, it is your side's challenge to the chargeback itself.

What is the difference between pre-arbitration and arbitration?

Pre-arbitration is still between the issuer and the acquirer. Arbitration is when the card network itself decides who is liable, and the losing side pays a review fee on top of the disputed amount.

How much does chargeback arbitration cost?

Visa's public rules say the responsible party pays the transaction amount and a review fee but do not publish the fee. Adyen's documentation lists a USD 600 filing fee for the loser of Visa arbitration and a fee of up to USD 600 for Mastercard. Your processor may add its own charges.

Can I take a Stripe dispute to arbitration?

No. Stripe's documentation says it does not support the arbitration phase, so a won or lost decision on Stripe is final. A customer can still withdraw a dispute, and in rare cases an issuer reverses a loss, which Stripe calls a late win.

Should I accept or decline pre-arbitration?

Decline only if the issuer brought nothing new that changes the facts and your evidence clearly answers the claim. If the amount is small next to a possible arbitration fee, or the issuer's new information is valid, accepting is usually cheaper.

Sources: Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (October 24, 2026 edition, sections 11.3, 11.12 and 11.13); MastercardDispute Resolution Cycle andPre-arbitration and pre-compliance case filing; AdyenVisa chargebacks,Mastercard chargebacks andDispute timeframes; StripeHow disputes work andRespond to disputes; PayPalmanaging chargebacks. Checked October 29, 2026.

Keep the evidence before you need it

Rebutdesk is an open-source helpdesk where Stripe and PayPal disputes open inside the buyer's support case, so the conversation, refunds and shipping events are already in order when the deadline starts. See how it works.

Start free trial

14 days free, no card needed. Already have an account? Sign in

More guides