What makes a return policy useful in a dispute
A return policy template is a starting point; what matters later is whether you can prove the buyer saw it. When a buyer files a chargeback for a refund they say they were owed, such as Visa 13.6 Credit Not Processed or13.7 Canceled Merchandise/Services, the policy is often your main evidence. Stripe's dispute evidence has separate fields for it:
| Stripe field | What Stripe asks for |
|---|---|
refund_policy | Your refund policy, as shown to the customer (a file). |
refund_policy_disclosure | Documentation that the customer was shown your refund policy before purchase. |
refund_refusal_explanation | Why the customer is not entitled to a refund. |
cancellation_policy, cancellation_policy_disclosure | The same for subscriptions: the cancellation policy and how it was shown. |
So the wording matters less than the display. Stripe's prevention advice is specific:
- Show the full policy on the checkout page, or in a pop-up the buyer has to agree to before ordering, not only as a link.
- A checkbox that contains only a link may be rejected by the issuer as evidence that the buyer knew the policy.
- Keep a dated copy of each version you publish, so you can show the one that applied on the order date.
Then follow the policy you wrote. Refunds you promise in a support thread and do not send lose disputes; our customer service email templates include polite replies for issuing and declining refunds that quote the policy back to the buyer. For the difference between a refund and a chargeback, see chargeback vs refund.
This is a template, not legal advice
Consumer law sets minimums that a store policy cannot take away, and they differ by country and state. Check the rules where your buyers live, and ask a lawyer if you are unsure. One common example is the EU right of withdrawal under the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU):
- Consumers who buy online can withdraw within 14 days without giving a reason. For goods, the 14 days start when the buyer takes physical possession of them (Article 9).
- If you do not tell buyers about this right, the period is extended by 12 months (Article 10).
- You must refund all payments, including standard delivery, within 14 days of being told of the withdrawal, to the original payment method; you may wait until the goods come back or the buyer shows proof of sending them (Article 13).
- The buyer pays the direct cost of returning goods only if you told them so in advance, and is liable only for loss of value from handling beyond what is needed to check the goods (Article 14). A flat restocking fee on EU withdrawals is therefore risky.
- Exceptions include personalized or made-to-order goods, sealed goods unsealed after delivery that cannot be returned for health or hygiene reasons, sealed recordings or software that were unsealed, and digital content once delivery started with the buyer's express consent and acknowledgment that they lose the right (Article 16).
The "We sell to consumers in the EU" option above adds a section along these lines and warns you when a setting conflicts with it. It does not cover the separate legal guarantee for faulty goods, or the rules of other countries.
Questions
What should a return policy include?
The return window and when it starts, the condition items must be in, how to start a return, who pays return shipping, how and when refunds are paid, whether you offer exchanges, what cannot be returned, and how damaged or wrong items are handled. Add sections for digital products and subscriptions if you sell them.
Is a refund policy the same as a return policy?
They are usually one page. The return part says how goods come back; the refund part says how money goes back. Stripe's evidence calls it the refund policy, so make sure the refund terms are explicit, not implied.
Can I offer no refunds at all?
You can state a final-sale policy where the law allows it, but it does not override statutory rights such as the EU 14-day withdrawal right, and buyers can still dispute faulty or undelivered orders. A clear, visible policy helps you win the disputes that are about a change of mind.
Evidence fields from Stripe's Dispute object; display advice fromBest practices for preventing fraud. EU rules from Directive 2011/83/EU Articles 9,10,13,14 and16 (text as adopted) and the European Commission's Your Europe guide to returns. Checked October 29, 2026.
Collect the evidence as it happens
Rebutdesk is an open-source helpdesk where Stripe and PayPal disputes open inside the buyer's support case. The messages, refunds and notes are already there, in order, when the deadline starts. See how it works.
14 days free, no card needed. Already have an account? Sign in